Mayhem and more mayham as Social Security realizes the error made last month when processing payments and deductions as some sole traders renewed their right to continue receiving Sole Trader “Unemployment” Benefits whereas others opted out.

The situation is as follows… Around 250.000 business owners chose to continue receiving unemployment benefits whilst trade is still slow due to Covid-19 but many who had been receiving payments decided to discontinue either because business had picked up and they could manage without additional help or because their income forecast for summer trade would exceed the maximum permitted by Social Security to qualify for benefits.

Those who discontinued benefits would instead receive reduced rates on their Social Security contributions from June to September; now, my clients in this situation will remember when I said at the time that since it was possible to apply for continued benefits until August, it is likely Social Security would charge as normal in June and July and wait to see which business owners are still receiving payments and then deduct two months contributions at the end of August as that seemed the most logical course of action. However, this did not happen and surprisingly, Social Security implemented deductions straight away.

This is partly where the problem lies because not only did they apply deductions virtually across the board meaning that many sole traders only paid 10% of their normal monthly contribution even though they had applied to continue receiving payments; but the Mutuas correctly refunded these sole traders a percentage of the Social Security contribution as part of their benefits payment.

What does this mean? Well, not only were the affected sole traders charged 90% less by Social Security but they were also reimbursed part of the contribution by the Mutua (double whammy!) so in many cases, these business owners now owe Social Security a minimum of 250 euros depending on their base rate.

How has this happened? Social Security and the Mutuas are independent entities so the information is not picked up immediately, so Social Security did not have the necessary data to determine who was entitled to the 90% reduced rate in June. Again, this is why at the time I had assumed they would wait until the end of August before applying any deductions as they would have sufficient information by then but they didn’t do that.

The second scenario is that other business owners are owed money by Social Security because they paid the full contribution in June when they should have only paid 10%. In this case, they must request the appropriate refund directly.

The third and final scenario is those sole traders who had been receiving benefits until May but opted not to renew this right correctly paid 10% of their normal contribution in June and will continue receiving discounts until September. In this case, the sole trader neither owes nor is owed anything.

Bottom line… Check your June bank statement to see what Social Security you paid and what you received from the Mutua to verify whether you are one of the affected business owners who now owes Social Security. If you are unsure, please contact me about it. So far Social Security has not released clear information as to how they intend on regulating these payments, but I’m sure they are working on a way to fix this big mistake!


INSUFFICIENT HELP DURING THE PANDEMIC’S SECOND WAVE: According to information released by ATA (Association for Sole Traders), each day there are 500 small businesses that close doors forever and these business owners as well as those who perhaps continue to struggle amidst the crisis feel that not enough is being done EIGHT MONTHS into the pandemic.

Although I’m sure the government has done and continues to do everything in its power to provide assistant to individuals and business owners alike, if you think about it, the measures in place allow for employees to be placed on furlough and for the business owners to receive a maximum of 661 euros per month, but is this enough? I could not imagine being in the hot seat and being responsible for passing legislation and making the tough decisions to ensure Spain’s stability at this uncertain time, but maybe it is time for further measures to be agreed…

The critics feel it is time to reraise the question about whether it is plausible for sole traders to contribute at Social Security in accordance to their income instead of a standardized rate calculated by the Administration as it is now. At present, the 661 euros per month financial aid is based on a general calculation that has nothing to do with each individual’s standard of life.

What does this mean? Sole Traders contribute each month as per a Base Rate calculated by Social Security, whereas other European countries contribute in accordance to their income. In this current scenario, those who requested financial aid because the government initially shut down their business activity or because of decreased revenue receive monthly benefits based on the Base Rate and not on their income. So, whether your business generates a monthly profit of 500 euros or 10.000 euros, the benefits received are the same.

This method has affected people at the top end of the spectrum because it is not the same to have monthly outgoings of 5.000 euros as opposed to somebody else’s outgoings of 2.000 euros and only receive 661 euros per month as this would not cover their living expenses. If however, they contribute every month according to their real income, their finacial aid could perhaps be calculated on the average over the past 12 months and the monthly benefits received would allow them to cover their expenses in line with their lifestyle.

Contributions based on real income is a double-edged sword. Even I can see the logistical issues with this and I have commented on this many times over the past few years. Sole Trader Associations have raised this problem on numerous occasions and although Social Security has agreed to consider the possibility, nothing has come of it. The only reason I can think of is that they cannot trust business owners to be honest and decare their real income. If the majority were to underdeclare, I believe we could effectively say “adiós” to the Spanish Social Security system as it exists now because there would not be sufficient funds available to cover unemployment, sick pay, not to mention pensions.

In light of the pandemic and how people have been forced to cope over the last eight months with limited resources, I feel it is only logical for this subject to be reopened and discussed in real terms, but I am not optimistic about a positive outcome simply because of the millions that have been spent from the budget this year alone. Yet, it must also be said that if the majority could be responsible and honest in their declarations, there is no reason why this couldn’t be a way forward and it may even encourage thousands more to register their businesses legally without the pressure of a minimum 286-euro monthly contribution before getting a chance to earn for themselves.


These past few days have been quite busy on the business owner front, whether it has been to do with Social Security or financial aid authorized by the Spanish Government, but I’m going to give you insights into what has been going on lately.

As you must be aware, Social Security increased monthly contributions on 30th October 2020 as per Royal Decree 28/2018, 28th December that outlined progressive increases from 2019 to 2021 that incorporate obligatory payment of Professional Accidents, Business Closure (Sole Trader Unemployment) and Professional Training which up until that point were voluntary.

Due to the pandemic, the annual increase, that usually takes place in January, was delayed until October. According to statistics, 77% of sole traders contribute the minimum base rate, which means an increase from 283,30 euros per month to 286,15 euros per month. The increase applied varies from approximately 2,84 euros to 12,12 euros depending on age and applicable base rate.

Tomorrow, Monday 30th November 2020, Social Security will implement two important matters in relation to governmental financial aid:

  1. Those who requested a continuance for sole trader financial aid will receive payment and this will extend until 31st January 2021. Depending on your circumstances, you will either receive 472 euros (50% of the base rate) or 661 euros (70% of the base rate). The number of applicants has almost doubled since the last count. In October 256.000 sole traders requested financial aid, however, it would seem that this has risen to around 500.000 beneficiaries.
  2. Those sole traders who requested deferment on their monthly contribution will begin to pay back their debt to Social Security from Monday 30th November 2020. At the start of the pandemic, the Government permitted this option to certain collectives to temporarily alleviate financial pressures by not charging fees for May, June and July, but now it is time to pay back the piper, so the back payments will be added onto the usual monthly contribution (a minimum of 572,30 euros). Statistics do show though that not many business owners requested this form of financial aid.

Although these measures have proved invaluable to those who have been affected economically by this health crisis, there is an outcry from those who feel that not enough is being done. Please take a read of the following article for more information, https://www.canaryadminservices.com/will-the-pandemic-restart-conversations-about-social-security-contributions/


As the month of September comes to a close, so does the financial aid some sole traders are still receiving from the Central Government via their Mutuas. What plans are in place for sole traders after the 30th September?

Well, there has been a lot of chatter over recent weeks from associations that represent sole trader interests about extending financial aid, but nothing definitive has been confirmed so far. This of course is of great concern to affected business owners because we are still nowhere near anything that resembles “normal”. In fact, the situation has not progressed much over the past few months; although lockdown as we experienced it is over, travel is still restricted with many countries implementing quarantine periods after returning from Spain which does not help our tourism dependent islands.

Two of Spain’s most prominent sole trader associations, UPTA and ATA were given a seat at the table to ensure the plight of business owners was not overlooked in government discussions, and they were the main force behind the extension of financial aid that was approved in June. However, this was based on the premise that more than 90% of sole traders would restart their business activity after the state of emergency concluded when experts predicted the pandemic would “wind down” until at least October, giving us a chance to recoup summer losses. As we know, this prediction did not come true. With this in mind, the associations have made the following proposals for the Government to consider:

  1. To extend employees on furlough to 1st April 2021
  2. To extend sole trader special financial aid (the version that is compatible with continuing their business activity) until 1st April 2021
  3. Re-estabishing extraordinary financial aid for those businesses whose activity has been impacted by current limitations or by new outbreaks
  4. To reduce Social Security contributions until 1st April 2021 for those sole traders who have suffered losses equal or superior to 50% in the 3rd Quarter 2020 compared to the 3rd Quarter 2019
  5. To extend ICO line of credit until 1st April 2021 as well as a grace period up to 24 months
  6. To temporarily reduce IVA (mainland Spain equivalent of IGIC) up to 50% for hospitality, tourism and culture sectors plus hairdressers and gyms
  7. To increase deferment of taxes until 1st April 2021
  8. Tax relief for sole traders (personal tax) and companies (corporate tax) who have maintained the same level of employment in 2020
  9. To extend limits of those business that operate under the fixed-tax system (módulos) until 2022
  10. To create a network of business mentors to help prevent the risk of bankruptcy and advisory services geared towards digitalizing businesses

The presidents of both associations are adamant their negotiations with the government will be successful resulting in new lines of financial aid and credit to struggling business owners, deeming it “inconceivable” to question that assistance will be made available during these difficult times, especially since some regions have returned to a lockdown state.

According to Social Security, more than 140.000 sole traders have received financial aid and that more than 154 million euros have been spent in this concept so far.

We can only hope that within the next few days, more information comes to light and definitive agreements are reached to provide business owners with the assistance they need and deserve to keep their businesses afloat. I wish you all the best and as always, stay safe.

If you would like to receive advice for your own business or if you are looking to change asesoría, please contact me for further information to arrange a personalized consult.


Following on from yesterday’s email, Royal Decree-Law 8/2020 was published yesterday to complement Royal Decree 463/2020, 14th March.

The chain reaction the outbreak of COVID-19 as caused throughout the world that initially concentrated in China, interrupting much of the world’s production and manufacturing output has now filtered down to other dependent sectors, affecting export and supply.

We have also seen the direct impact it is having on domestic finances, the closure of schools, the cancellation of public events, flight and other transport bans that have primarily shaken the tourist industry, not to mention the effect on the global stock market. The limitations imposed on us since last Saturday have meant restrictions on freedom of movement, quarantine which have generated incredible issues within the family unit and businesses alike, especially for those families whose income derives from the type of activities that have been temporarily banned by the government.

The government’s priority right now is to minimize as much as possible the impact of this lockdown and facilitate measures to ensure we can all bounce back as soon as the situation improves.

Some of you emailed me yesterday about the new situation and as mentioned in my previous email, I spent the day reading through and clarifying certain points of the decree that were not  so I can summarize its key points to you. If after reading this email, you still have queries or concerns about your situation, please do not hesitate to contact me again. Since there has been no official has been published about Holiday Lets, the only thing I will say at this time is that there is a difference between the types of accommodation being mentioned (hotels, camping and caravan sites…) and self-contained units such as private apartments and villas. Hotels and similar call for groups of people to be attended to in the dining area for example as the rooms are not self-sufficient, so this closure may only refer to these types of accommodation. This is not official as mentioned, only my own deductions, however, if your property is currently occupied, remember, the government is encouraging people to return to their countries of residence until this crisis is resolved mainly because airspace is due to be closed down or greatly reduced.

According to this Royal Decree-Law, the following measures have been approved:

1.- Extraordinary Social Security benefits for closure of business activity for those affected by the declared State of Emergency in order to regulate the health crisis produced by COVID-19:

a) Exceptionally and limited to one month1 from the date in which Royal Decree 463/2020, 14th March came into effect when the State of Emergency was officially announced, those sole traders whose business activities were shut down have the right to these “unemployment” benefits as long as the following criteria is met:

  • To be affiliated and currently registered as a sole trader (Régimen Especial de la Seguridad Social de los Trabajadores Autónomos) or at least on the date the State of Emergency was announced (14th March 2020)
  • In the event, your business activity was not directly shut down by virtue of the above-mentioned Decree, you must provide evidence that your billing during the month prior to applying for unemployment benefits has been greatly reduced by at least 75% in comparison to the average billed over the six previous months
  • To be up to date in payment of all Social Security contributions. If this is not the case, they allow a maximum of 30 days in which to make these payments and access unemployment benefits

1 Unemployment benefits would be extended to the last day of the month in which the State of Emergency concludes, should this situation last more than one month

b) The benefit amount is calculated by applying 70% of the average base rate you have paid over the last twelve months, which is to say, twelve consecutive months and immediately prior to applying. If the applicant has not been registered as self-employed for twelve months, therefore not meeting the normal criteria, the benefit amount applicable would be the equivalent of 70% of the minimum base rate

c) As stated, the duration of this extraordinary benefit is one month, which could be extended to the end date of the State of Emergency, however, this time would be recorded as if you had continued paying into the system as normal, i.e., it does not interrupt your registry as self-employed and it does not reduce the time you may receive this same benefit if you have to apply again in future (for a situation unrelated to COVID-19

d) Receipt of unemployment benefits mean you would not be liable to pay Social Security contributions. For those who continue their business activity, you must pay the monthly contribution as normal

e) Receipt of unemployment benefits is incompatible with any other Social Security benefits

f) Working partners linked to co-operatives will be granted the same rights to access these benefits as long as they meet the requirements established above

IMPORTANT NOTE: The Decree does not mention if this applies to Sole Traders registered as Family Collaborators. I am trying to find out whether they would have the right to unemployment after the principal Sole Trader applies.

 

2.- Measures to regulate employee contracts to avoid dismissals:

a) There is a system in place for those businesses that have suffered the most severe losses due to forces beyond their control such as this health crisis called ERTE (Expediente de Regulación Temporal de Empleo). What is the definition of forces beyond control in this situation?:

  • Suspension or cancellation of business activities
  • Temporary closure of premises open to the public
  • Restrictions on public transport
  • General restrictions and freedom of movement of people and/or merchandise
  • Loss of provisions that hinder the normal development of the business
  • Contagion within the company
  • When extraordinary measures of preventative self-isolation have been enforced in the company

b) In the case of those businesses that on 29th February had less than 50 employees, Social Security will absorb the business owner’s obligatory payments 100%. In the case of those businesses that on 29th February had more than 29th February had 50 employees or more, Social Security will absorb 75% of the business owner’s obligatory payments. These obligatory payments referred to here DO NOT include the business owner’s own monthly Social Security contribution

c) Employees affected by the ERTE system have the right to receive unemployment even if they have not been registered employees for a full year as normally required by law

d) Businesses that choose the ERTE system are obligated to maintain all employees in the company for at least SIX MONTHS after business activities return to normal

e) Social Security must respond to the application within 5 days

f) Employees who have dependents (minors or elderly) should be permitted to take leave to see to their family in the best way possible, however, employees who are absent from their place of work for unjustified reasons may be dismissed (the proper procedure must be followed)

 

3.- Business Line of Credit:

The Ministry of Economic Affairs will grant a line of credit to ensure cash flow in affected companies (payment of invoices, financial or tax obligations or other cash flow issues). The maximum amount is 100.000 euros and conditions are being drafted

 

4.- Extensions for Mortgage Loans:

a) For those who have especially difficult circumstances due to the COVID-19 crisis and are unable to make mortgage repayments on their mortgages, special measures apply for their primary residence only

b) Those debtors that fall under the category of “economic vulnerability” as established in Article 9 of the Decree-Law (or point c of this document) and whose contracts are currently in effect. These same measures apply to guarantors of the debtors

c) Definition of economic vulnerability:

  • The debtor has been made unemployed or in the case of sole traders, has suffered a substantial loss of income or a substantial fall in sales
  • That the total income of the family unit does not exceed the income received in the month prior to applying for the extension
        • In general terms, the limit of three times the monthly Indicador Público de Renta de Efectos Múltiples (IPREM)
        • The above limit will increase by 0,1 the IPREM for each dependent child or 0,15 for each child in a single-parent household
        • The general limit will increase by 0,1 for each family member over the age of 65
        • If any family member has a declared disability higher than 33%, dependent situation or illness that does not permit them to work, the general limit will be four times the stipulate IPREM, regardless of any increases

There is still a little bit of uncertainty about some of these measures as procedures have not been clearly outlined etc., and the Administrations themselves are not entirely sure what the logistics would be, but if you would like to proceed with any of these options, please contact me to discuss how best to move forward. If not, it is business as usual until we all come out fighting the other side.

As always, take care

1 2 3 6